Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater
Pizza Restaurants in Clearwater, Florida
4.5 (373)
| Category | Pizza Restaurants · Family restaurant, Pizza delivery, Italian restaurant, Pizza Takeout |
|---|---|
| Address | 2481 McMullen Booth Rd D, Clearwater, FL 33759 |
| Area | Clearwater, Florida |
| Phone | (727) 754-5242 |
| Google rating | 4.5 (373) |
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
|---|---|
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
About Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater
Pizzitalia’s Clearwater is a family-friendly, full-service Italian restaurant serving New York-style pizza, classic pasta dishes, Italian entrées, fresh salads, appetizers, sandwiches and desserts. Enjoy great food and music, watch live sports on multiple TVs and a large projector, and explore our selection of draft beverages. Kids can have fun at our gaming stations, while our welcoming space is also perfect for family gatherings, private events, birthday parties and group celebrations. Join us for lunch or dinner, or enjoy convenient takeout and delivery.
Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater is one of the pizza restaurants listed in Clearwater, Florida. The business is registered at 2481 McMullen Booth Rd D, Clearwater, FL 33759; use this page to check its hours, phone number and Google rating before you make the trip. Google also lists it under family restaurant, pizza delivery, italian restaurant, which is worth knowing if you are comparing several options in the area.
Pizza places in the United States run from a counter with two stools and a stack of boxes to a full sit-down pizzeria with a bar, and most neighborhood shops do all three things at once: dine-in, takeout and delivery. Ordering by phone is still common and often faster than an app, and many independents charge less when you call direct because there is no platform fee. Sizes are usually listed in inches (a small around 10", a large 14", an extra-large 16" or more), and a large feeds two to three adults. Slices are sold from a display case at New York-style counters and reheated to order; whole pies take 15-25 minutes at a busy shop. Most spots take cards and mobile pay, though a few older pizzerias remain cash-only, so check the door or the listing before you order.
The business lists hours on 2 days of the week. Typical hours are 11 AM–9 PM. As with most places, expect changes around holidays; the phone number below is the fastest way to confirm. You can reach Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater at (727) 754-5242; calling is usually the quickest way to ask about availability, prices or directions. Its website is pizzitalias.com, where you may find menus, price lists or booking options.
Customers rate it 4.5 out of 5 on Google across 373 reviews, placing it among the better-regarded pizza restaurants in Clearwater.
Clearwater is in Florida, in the Southeast, where summers are long, hot and humid, winters are mild, and afternoon thunderstorms and the hurricane season from June to November can change plans at short notice. Traffic in Clearwater peaks on weekday mornings and afternoons, so allow extra time then. Addresses read from the street number up to the city, state abbreviation and five-digit ZIP code; the map link on this page shows the exact spot.
Looking for alternatives? Browse all pizza restaurants in Clearwater or explore other categories in the area from the links below. If you own or manage Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater, you can claim this listing to correct details, add photos and a description, and receive a verified badge. Everyone else can help by leaving an honest review on Google after a visit.
Latest Google reviews
The 5 most recent reviews shown on Google Maps. Reviews belong to their authors; read all of them on Google.
Ariel Perkowski 2 months ago
Used to order here a lot when it was Infinity. We ordered tonight since I have ordered even after the change and it was great before. $70 for 2 pizzas and garlic knots. The garlic knots were okay at best and the pizzas were absolutely awful. I would expect to get better pizza at a dive bar. As soon as I opened the box I knew this was actually insane to be charging this amount for. Very sad.
Caroline Hendrix a year ago
NOT INFINITY PIZZA!!! The good reviews/rating/pricing no longer apply as this is just a bar using the reputation of the previous business. The service was depressing and the vibe was off. Upon walking in, there's an offputting smell and prepared to feel baked under the chaotic lights.If you have a small child, be prepared to wait 15 minutes for a highchair that they borrow from the hair salon next door. We called ahead for a party of 8 and there was like maybe 2 and a half tables of people there, but the staff will ignore you and act overwhelmed if your order anything beyond an alcoholic beverage. 45 minute wait for apps and an hour for your pizza. There's no consistency as their garlic knots and marinara are good but the pizza will look good but the dough will be thick&thin all over, almoat no sauce and heat-lamped stiff, making the crust hard. The pricing is way too high, $22 for a medium and $30 for a large with $2 toppings. Soda is $3 and you will have to beg for a refill but only some of you will actually get one. You will get checked on only once 5 minutes after getting your food and thats it for the next hour. Ask for the check multiple times and watch as they forget you exi
Nicole Tarsan Edited 4 months ago
May 2026 edit: not sure what’s happening here. Very limited drink selection. A/C broken. Too hot to sit for 2hrs. At least our pizza was good, but probably last time we will be in for trivia. Sad. SO SO happy!! Good pizza is back!! New owner of Nautical Brews is awesome. We are back at it with Trivia Thursdays. Bring all your friends for good food & good times!!
Taylor Chandler a year ago
We went in on a Thursday for trivia and had such a wonderful experience! We ordered the Keel Farms Elderberry hard cider, Florida Ave Dead parrot lager, garlic knots, garlic bread, caprese pizza, and the margarita pizza... FANTASTIC!!! The new staff is attentive, fun, and very upbeat!!! Cold beer, delicious food, and a great atmosphere... what more could you ask for? We will be going back.... in the regular! CAN'T RECOMMEND ENOUGH!!!
rkelleher84 a year ago
I don't write a lot of reviews, but this place definitely deserves recognition. Some buddy's and I stopped in after a long hot day of playing paintball to grab a few beers and a bite. We ordered a couple small pizzas (margarita and white) and wings (buffalo). First of all, the white pizza was absolutely perfect. It's hard to find a decent white pizza but these guys have a perfect one. The crust is cold fermented New York style and cooked to absolute perfection. Easily some of the best crust I've had in all of Pinellas. Service was perfect. Beer was cold and delicious. We'll be going back!
Frequently asked questions
Where is Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater located?
Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater is at 2481 McMullen Booth Rd D, Clearwater, FL 33759, in Clearwater, Florida. Use the “Open in Google Maps” button on this page for directions.
What kind of business is Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater?
Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater is listed as a pizza restaurant and is also tagged on Google as family restaurant, pizza delivery, italian restaurant.
What are the hours of Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater?
Published hours are Monday: 11 AM–9 PM; Sunday: 11 AM–9 PM. Hours can change on holidays, so call before a special trip.
Is Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater open on Sunday?
Yes, on Sunday it is open 11 AM–9 PM.
What is the phone number of Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater?
You can call Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater at (727) 754-5242.
How is Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater rated on Google?
Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater has a Google rating of 4.5 out of 5 from 373 reviews.
Does Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater have a website?
Yes, the website of Pizzitalia’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Clearwater is pizzitalias.com (linked on this page).
More pizza restaurants in Clearwater
All pizza restaurants in Clearwater →Verola's Pizzeria
Pizza Restaurants · Clearwater, Florida
Cheese Wheel Pasta & Pizza
Pizza Restaurants · Clearwater, Florida
Cristino's Coal Oven Pizza
Pizza Restaurants · Clearwater, Florida
Clear Sky Cafe
Pizza Restaurants · Clearwater, Florida
Paul's Chicago Pizza
Pizza Restaurants · Clearwater, Florida
Gulfside Pizza & Subs
Pizza Restaurants · Clearwater, Florida
